Subaru WRX Forum banner

Recently purchased a 2021 WRX Premium and now I don't what to sell my 2011 Premium - comparisons.

1 reading
3.9K views 10 replies 7 participants last post by  WRXEnthusiast8  
#1 ·
So I wanted something more reliable as I started to put more money than I would like into my 2011, so I purchased a 2021 with 20K miles. So far, it's been a struggle to love this car the same way as the 2011. Anytime I get back into the 2011, it feel like home and I really don't want to sell it. It has 135k miles on it with absolutely no mods (normal driving), and it's been really good to me up until about 120k when it started to eat $1500-2000 every several months.

I feel very disconnected from the 2021. From the missing EJ25/unequal rumble, the transmission feel, the ludicrous throttle response, the unstable power band, the terrible sound system, to the little things like my windows rattling when cracked and hitting bumps. I'm hoping it will grow on me, but I don't want to go down the rabbit hole of modding everything to make it feel like it should have been from the factory. I also have a 10 year warranty, so "reliability" with a little fun is the goal.

I just can't comprehend why my 2011 with 135k miles feel like the new car, and my new (to me) 2021 feel like the old car.
The 2011 transmission feels amazing, shifts like butter, the seats/ride is more comfortable, the stock premium sound is fantastic and the lists goes on.

The hard part is that for the 135k miles on the 2011, I can get pretty good money for it at the moment. I just have a feeling I will regret selling it and would try to find a used one again - loosing all the maintenance work I have done over the last couple years (the whole clutch system is new, new stock turbo, timing belt and pulleys/water pump/temp sensor/all gaskets near timing belt, etc).

Should I just keep it and throw an IAG in when the motor finally starts to give or take the money and run while the used market is silly? I feel like every gripe I have with the 2021 involves spending more money or voiding my warranty, and I had great luck with my stock 2011, so Im hesitant to start modding heavily. So far just a super shifter stop and a STI pitch shift.

Thanks!
 
#2 ·
Reminds me of a saying... Good cars sell but quirky cars make enthusiasts.

FWIW I've never come to love my STI like I did my bugeye.

Sell it and you'll always remember it fondly.
 
#4 ·
It sounds like you didn't have to sell the '11 to buy the '21 so... can you not just continue to keep it? If you get hit with another big maintenance bill, since (if) it is your secondary car, seem you could just wait to take care of it until you feel like pulling the trigger. Secondarily, if you've put a bunch of money into it lately, don't you think you're almost done having to do that and now you can just enjoy it?
 
#5 ·
If you're having so many second thoughts about it that you have to reach out to strangers on the internet to make a decision, you may want to consider keeping the GR. I'd take a brand new GR WRX sedan over my VB WRX. I've owned both. I don't care what the numbers say, the GR is a lot more exciting than the VB, so it's probably even more exciting than the VA.

I have big regrets about getting rid of my VA STI for my VB WRX. Newer is not always better.
 
#9 ·
I avoided testing a 21 STI for that same reason ha. It was in the budget, but finding a used STI that has little done to it is way harder than finding an untouched WRX. People get a little too crazy with these cars, and you'll most likely be getting a "put everything back so it looks OEM" STI. That was my biggest deciding factor for little brother.
 
#8 ·
Appreciate all the feedback.

No, I don't have to sell the 2011 GE financially. It will cost me about $1400 a year for insurance and registration to hang on to it (plus whatever it's next big need is), so I can swing the extra cost to have a secondary vehicle. It's mainly the crazy used market price that's tempting me. People are selling them 30-40% over book value. I know financing a 30k car is hard for some these days due to the loan rates, so it seems like a good time to get top dollar for it.

I'll hang on to it till I make sure this 2021 is not hiding any serious issues, then make the decision.

Cheers!
 
#11 ·
I get it, there's something special about a car that's been with you through thick and thin. If it still feels like home and does the job, why rush to part ways? Plus, with all the TLC you've put into it, it's practically part of the family. Trust your instincts on this one! Oh, and if you're thinking about a new ride down the road, checking out some car lease deals might not be a bad idea.