Subaru WRX Forum banner

Effects of Upsized Wheels and Tires Tested - Tech Dept. - Car and Driver

13464 Views 14 Replies 13 Participants Last post by  SD_GR
Effects of Upsized Wheels and Tires Tested - Tech Dept. - Car and Driver

From the May 2010 Issue of Car and Driver

The aesthetic appeal of larger wheels and tires is undeniable, but what about the alleged performance benefits? In general, larger wheels are heavier, and additional weight hinders performance. To examine the effects of installing larger wheels and tires, also known as “plus-sizing,” we tested five wheel-and-tire combinations—ranging from 15 to 19 inches—on a 2010 Volkswagen Golf and got a good sense of what is gained and lost in the process.

The plus-size concept basically works like this: As the wheel gets larger in diameter, the size of the tire’s sidewall must shrink to maintain the tire’s overall diameter. Keeping the overall tire diameter roughly the same is crucial to keeping the gearing the same and the speedometer accurate, as well as for making sure the wheels and tires fit within the fenders. But larger-diameter wheels and tires are often available only in enlarged widths as well.

Our test employed nearly identical Goodyear Eagle GT ultra-high-performance all-season tires in all five sizes, inflated to manufacturer-recommended pressures. We say that the tires were nearly the same because the 15-, 16-, and 17-inchers have a lower speed rating (V, or a top speed up to 149 mph) than the 18- and 19-inch tires’ W-rating (up to 168 mph). This, however, was as close as we could get to testing the same tire in every size. We used the stock steel wheels for the 15-inch test and went to the aftermarket for the larger wheels, as most owners would do. The aftermarket wheel we chose was a cast-aluminum ASA GT1, which is available in 16- to 19-inch sizes on the Golf. It’s obvious from the test that as wheels and tires grow in size, they also grow in weight. Here’s how the test shook out:

What’s immediately apparent from the results is that as the wheel-and-tire packages get larger and heavier, acceleration and fuel economy suffer. Neither is a huge surprise, but we measured a 10-percent drop in fuel economy and a four-percent degradation in 0-to-60-mph acceleration from the 15s to the 19s, which is worth considering should you be thinking about “going big.” Increasing wheel diameter and width, in turn, requires wider tires with shorter and stiffer sidewalls, which we found will increase skidpad grip, but as our test shows, there is a limit to this assertion. The 19-inch package came with the widest tires (235/35R-19) mounted to the widest wheels (8.5 inches), but this setup had less grip around the skidpad than the narrower 225/40R-18s on 8.0-inch-wide wheels. We asked the folks at Goodyear why that might be, and they postulated that the added width may have given the outside tire more grip, which would increase body roll and could therefore decrease the load on the inside tire enough to lose 0.01 g on the skidpad.

Surprisingly, the 225/40R-18s showed a big skidpad advantage compared with the 225/45R-17s (0.89 g versus 0.85 g). We *suspect the difference is due to the grippier compound (lower wear rating) of the W-rated 18s. Goodyear does offer a W-rated GT in the 225/45R-17 size, which is what we intended to use, but Goodyear sent us the V-rated version for our test.

Subjectively, both the 17-inch and 18-inch wheels and tires were in the sweet spot of grip, braking performance, ride comfort, and steering feel. Moving from 17-inchers to 18s barely degrades ride quality, and the additional grip is welcome. We’d guess that a W-rated Eagle GT in the 17-inch size would come close to matching the grip of the W-rated 18, but we can’t say for certain without testing. Even with V-rated rubber, the performance of the 17s felt *similar to that of the 18s. But since the 18-inch setup costs only $112 more than the 17-inch package, we’d probably opt for the 18s if we lived in a region with smooth roads and looks were a priority.

We do know that the heavy, 19-inch setup suffered from the most impact harshness and seemed to tax the suspension the most. In contrast, the two smallest wheel-and-tire combos showed a propensity for more understeer on the skidpad but provided a more controlled and supple ride. And although it didn’t register on the dBA-meter, the 15- and 16-inch arrangements had a more pleasant sound quality than the larger tires.

The 19-inch wheels definitely look the coolest. But the 17- and 18-inch setups offer a better compromise of grip, acceleration, price, and ride harshness, so we’re not surprised VW uses 17- and 18-inch sizes on its hot Golf, the GTI. If it’s acceleration you’re after, stick with the smaller, lighter wheels and tires. And remember, unless you believe it is better to look good than to feel good, take our advice and stay away from extremely low-profile sidewalls and massively heavy wheels.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
1 - 15 of 15 Posts
Please make this a stickie
Really good info. I vote for sticky as well.
Great read! I third the sticky.
Fourthed - more people need to read this.
Stuck. Lighter wheels are better.
Thanks Bill!
Good article.

Sent from space using Tapatalk, I'm Rick James Bitch
Thank you. Now i'm sure what size i'm going with.
Will start new thread for width and spacing recommendations on the bugeye.
Hi Sasquatch!

Thanks for the info. I bought a '17 WRX with the 18" stock dark alloy wheels and stock sport/summer tires. I live in NE PA and the summer stock tire are absolutely awful in snow. Almost had several snow accidents in a Subaru! So I checked around and they don't make a good 18" snow tire for those rims. I had to go to Tire Rack and buy the complete rim/tire kit. General Altimax Arctic tires and Monte Titano bright aluminum honeycomb rims. It's a huge traction difference and the 17" rims ride better. I may stick with the 17" rims forever. They are that much smoother riding. Anyway--just my 2 cents worth. I'm looking for other people on this forum who have done this. Nice talking with you.
I'm with you Bob.D . . . I guess I just don't drive my car hard enough to realize the benefits of the larger wheels since I kinda like the slightly cheaper price point of the 17 inch rims along with that little extra bit of rubber to absorb some of the fairly rough roads here.

That said . . . in fairness . . . I have never driven a WRX on 18 inchers so I honestly have no real life comparison.
I have a 2010 WRX, with stock 17 inch wheels. whats the widest aftermarket wheel I can fit without having to alter my fender walls?
I have a 15' WRX. The original high performance Dunlop stock summer tire was fine, but noisy. Swapped onto the stock rims dedicated Pirelli winter tires for two years from Nov - April. Super fun and confident in snow and rain, and were actually much quieter and more comfortable ride quality than summer stock Dunlops. At around 45K I purchased an 18 inch rim and high performance summer tire package from tire rack. Firestone 255 width/w rated high performance summer tires mounted onto black Enkei 5 spoke rims. This 18 inch tire and rim package has actually provided the quietest ride of all 3 combos to date and incredible improvement in dry weather all out handling versus what I purchased new with factory installed Dunlops on 17 inch rims. Wider stance of the 18 inch rim with wider tires looks good and improves 3 season performance. Will need a new dedicated winter tire for stock 17 inch rims for next winter. Pirelli Sottozerros did me well. Any recommendations for best winter tire at value price?
See less See more
I'm gonna disagree that the 19s look the coolest. 18 is the sweet spot for my eye. Anything bigger, and the wheel brings too much attention to itself, even distracting you from the car itself.

I pretty much detest the 19s that come on the STi right now. The finish, the design, the size, all of it.

And I think I can (temporarily) get behind the 18s that deliver on the 2021 Limited. When I pick up my car in 2 weeks, we'll see how long they last...
I’m just disappointed Subaru switched to 5X114 wheels, drying up supplies of factory 5X100s for us with the older cars.

For me, smaller is smarter. I’m on the factory 16s and just out new rubber on them, and every time I think about going up to 17s it doesn’t make sense to me.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
1 - 15 of 15 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.