2009 WRX Hatch with High mileage - needs opinion

I would call your insurance and have the windshield replaced. I would get a really nice detail and talk to them about paint safe dent removal people they trust to pull out what they can.

I would then sell the car privately and grab use the cash to help buy a new car. no way would i trade it in. there is no such thing as a fair price for our cars. people will pay stupid prices for them for little to no reason.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Tapatalk

My bad tired fixed it

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Tapatalk

I agree with xjman...fix the window and get it detailed. Forget book value as people just want a WRX and will overlook the miles because it's all they can afford. I have 250 k on mine as well and take great pride in leaving much newer cars in the rearview. I also love no car payment, I enjoy improving my car rather than watching a brand new one go downhill.
All that said without seeing or driving your car I'd list it between 6-7k depending on condition. Current inspection and good tires and no engine lights go a long way when selling. Fix the window and get a detail and list it for a week or two and see what happens. Good luck