So I won't even waste my time telling you about the dealership I went to yesterday. All I'll say is they wanted to sell me the car for 3k OVER msrp and only give me $5500 for my car. So to any future owners: do NOT go to Prestige Subaru in Turnersville, NJ
On the other hand though, the dealership I went to today? Amazing!! Glanzmann Subaru in Feasterville, PA. They have been the only dealership to treat me like a normal person. They also are one of those no BS type dealerships. They're giving me a great price on the WRX and also offering me a great trade in for the Bimmer.
I am going back tomorrow to put a deposit down and order the car.
'11 WRX Premium 5-door
Dark Grey Metallic
Arm Rest Extension
Media Hub (which apparently is standard on the premium? All the other dealerships told me it wasn't)
I am SOO excited right now that I actually got a deal that was good enough to actually do. Thank you to everyone on this forum who has answered questions and given me advice.