Call around your local wrecking yards. Many cars are owned by elite, highly skilled drivers and as a result get driven into trees, so spares should not be hard to find. See if you can find a replacement in better shape than what you've got.
Also, shop around body shops because prices vary dramatically.
Incidentally, I doubt the nose of the car is in great shape, right? If the hood scoop is hurting the nose must be chipped too. You may want to ask around friends/relatives/etc. for a good place and if you are going to keep the car, see what it needs as far as paint -- it's cheaper to do it all at once rather than piecemeal. It's not inexpensive, mind you, but it's less.