Welcome to the oddities that are subaru. lol..
When I first got my 2010 it was super quiet.. then as it got cold the car came alive like the woods do at night. There were ticks/buzzes coming from all over the place.
if its in the middle of the dash there may not be much the dealer can do about it.. but wouldn't hurt to bring it to them and say something about it. I bought some stick on foam and fixed all mine myself. Either way, its a normal subaru thing to have the interior buzz/creak. I'm not sure anymore if mine has quieted down some since I got it.. or if I just dont hear its little quirks anymore.
It is annoying that a car that new makes noise though isn't it? .. I was pretty ticked.. but.. the rest of the car outweighs its minor flaws.