What type of bike are you riding? I have a front loader, and I really like the idea of a very secure way to transport with the axle being threaded in, but I have a Trek Fuel and the front fork drop outs are very thick and will not fit. I had to buy an adapter for 50 dollars so that I could use the same set up basically, but now no locking for security if parked in a lot or something, but a chain lock would fix that My quick release axle is threaded so it takes a bit longer for me to remove and install my front wheel, but doesnt bother me and i know my bike wont shake off the rack or whatever. My buddy who I ride with has a full down hill set up, with triple crown forks and everything, big beast, he picked up INA388 / inno (RV-Inno) / ADVANCED CAR RACKS, . Basically it just holds both tires, and is muuuuch quicker to load and unload, and comes with a chain lock. Its a very good price also and fits the oem rack Both are very good products and I would be happy with either, just depending on what your wanting to ride and how quickly and often you load and unload.