the si requires premium fuel too
This is a discussion on Real world comparison for a new DD:'12/'13 WRX and '13 SI within the Comparison: WRX vs World forums, part of the Community - Meet other Enthusiasts category; the si requires premium fuel too...
I'm 6'4 205lbs and I own a 11' WRX. I love it and as stated before, the comfort level is pretty much on par with my roomates old 10' Si. He traded it in on a 12' MS3 just for performance reasons. I was not a fan of the long dashboards in the Si. Performance wise, I feel the WRX is on another level compared to the Civic. It is two completly different styles of fun when driving them so it is a preference with that. Gas in the Si was around 25,30 mpg with city driving. My wrx only gets 19-20 so I'm not very happy with that. Honestly, i'm 20 and I bought my car because of the performance upgrade compared to my 350z. You are 21 with a decent job and looking for a sporty car that is reliable. I would drive both and get the feel for them but I feel you would go with the WRX Hatch, which is what I have. If you didn't live so far away i'd say you could drive my car around and see what you think. ha.
RayfieldsWRX - "You like the feel of torque steer? Interesting"
jd92677 - "I like the idea of mashing the gas and not knowing which way the car will go."
I would just get the WRX if I were you..It's the best bang for the back
2012 Volkswagen 6spd man. GTI coupe BFI stage2 torque mount , H&R 24mm rear ARB, AFE STAGE 2 intake system, UR DP+ Magnaflow CBE, s3 shifter, neuspeed TOP and throttlebody pipe . UR mid-chassis brace. Unitronic Stage 2 software, Newsouth boostgauge
Also, ground and pound your dealer no matter what car you buy. Do your research and know what you want to pay before walking in. Dont waiver with add ons and such, the wrx is very popular around me and I still payed 800 below invoice. This was my first car but I did my homework and caught the dealer a couple of times trying to take advantage of me. Persistance and knowledge will get you the deal you want.
I can pretty much appreciate almost all cars but a Prius...I'm old, grew up during the Honda/Acura Prime and loved them. Got deployed came back and payed cash for a Scion tC..enjoyed the Scion craze also. The Army sent me to WV where Subaru's, Mustangs, and S-10's and uh oh wait Cavaliers with fart-cans rule. Can't say the Subaru interior will be a game changer-materials not-so-great, stereo I was told is made by Clarion(hear say-not fact). AWD = Awesome in the snow, dirt, gravel, twisty tarmac, and on the moon. Performance bang for your buck it is hard to beat the WRX. Hatch or Sedan / 4 doors is practical in many ways if you have a family,lower insurance premiums and quick escape if somebody cuts the cheese. Subaru community is genuine and likely to piss you off and make you feel loved at the same time. I have not walked up to any Hondas lately to give a thumbs up. They don't give me the fizz feeling like TopGear's James May gets. The WRX will give ya a bon3r at times. I'm on 3rd WRX since 2009. When I sold my 1st 07 WRX for an 08 VW GTI I really did fall into a depression, No more bon3rs,no more balls, I couldn't go on forums, I just didn't feel the same. I didn't leave the house for like 6 mos. My wife was driving an 08 WRX and rubbed it in my face every day. Finally my balls grew back, I kicked her butt into the VW and traded her 08 for my 2012 WRX Sedan, the bon3rs they're back! Viagra on wheels brother. My kid turns 16 in 6yrs right when its paid for and he'll be able to enjoy one of the last 2.5L gas-guzzling all around fun - proper cars of its time that is under 26k. Sorry to all that read this....it is part of my therapy.
Last edited by subaken; 05-16-2012 at 08:59 PM.
My 15 year old CRV was destroyed in storm. I have been a honda fan boy my whole life and Im old . I was really wanting a 2012 si sedan but when I went for a test drive I really didn't feel it. The interior was cool, radio sounded nice but the car just felt...lame. My wife and I were on our way home rather disappointed when we passed a newly opened Subaru dealership. Having long been a tuner car guy I have always been intrigued by the WRX. When I saw the WRX sedan I was really impressed with the look and feel of it. When I drove it, I knew I was home Not to mention that every Honda dealer we visited seemed to only house high pressure salesmen that knew nothing about what they were selling. The Subaru salesman actually knew about cars and educated me for a change. Nothing wrong with the Si but that was my though process.
I regret not getting an SI instead of my WRX
The SI has sharper handling and is overall more fun and feels faster, even though it is not.
The reason why I ended up getting the WRX is mainly because of the exhaust note (with an aftermarket exhaust obviously) and it is a little more quick out of the box...
But overall the SI can handle a lot more power and abuse if you are going to be modding the car. The stock block in the SI and the transmission in the SI can take a LOT more abuse than the WRX.
The WRX has rather pathetic gas mileage when you drive it even semi-hard and the handling is just not there without extensive aftermarket suspension work.. Not to mention that the factory tune has a lean spot and they like to blow up when you actually drive the damn car.
The fuel economy is not as good on the WRX as the civic, but that is too be expected since the WRX is heaver, makes 35% more HP and is AWD.
As far as the civic handling more power, the stock block on a WRX can supposedly handle 375 - 400 WHP and use it on the street. Even if you build a 500 WHP civic, and the block and trans lives (which it won't) you won't ever be able to use that power without slicks on the front.
So while I do really like the new civic, its not really a fair comparison in stock or mildly modified form. If you apply similar mods to both cars the WRX still wins in my book but again the WRX is a more expensive car. Now, if we are talking Lexan windows, no interior, full race cars with unlimited budgets who knows which is better, I guess, but I didn't buy a new brand new car for that purpose. My WRX is my first non-honda tuner car and I can tell you from person experience, turbo charging a car that didn't come that way from the factory is a rabbit hole that neither me nor my wallet wish to travel down again anytime soon.
There is a difference between numbers on paper and real life performance. Sounds illogical? Well, not really. This is why a low 14 sec Honda will hang with some low 13 sec cars on the freeway. Sure, the AWD will get a good 60' with a good launch and that is where that second in the 1/4 mile is shaved off. You aren't going to be launching it that way every time you take off and once you are already in motion, you are just "a little quicker" than the SI out-of the box.
To me the WRX really lacks spirit; it is very "robotic" and doesn't feel like a sports car. Sure, the SI doesn't exactly feel like a sports car either but overall is a bit more enthusiast-oriented for spirited driving. Of course you will argue that this is just my opinion, which is certainly true.
As for a WRX handling 400whp on the stock block and transmission, I haven't seen too many of those. The K-series can actually handle more than 500whp but that is also based on what I have personally seen and there is no 100% guarantee that it will be reliable for X amount of miles. I ran 2 boosted Hondas in the past on stock block and more than doubled the stock power and tuned the cars myself with no issues and I ran them pretty hard. Based on what I have seen, WRX cannot take that much abuse daily. But I didn't exactly get the WRX to mod it heavily, it is just a daily beater at this point with an exhaust note that is pleasing to my ears.
I'm coming from a supercharged 2009 civic si, I have a 2012 stage 2 pbp wrx sedan. My civic had everything done to it bolt on wise and suspension wise, i had a little over $10,000 in parts on it. The wrx with factory suspension feels better in the corners and the car shows its true colors after you flash a new map. My wrx has boat loads of torque compared to my old civic. I have less than $2,000 dollars into the car so far and it's quicker than the civic was. The only thing i miss about my civic was the digital speedo. Other than that. WRX all the way
And also.. my civic was making a little over 300whp and right at 200 ft lbs of tq. All it did was spin. 1st 2nd and 3rd gear. Not practical. And that was on dry pavement, lets not even talk about when it raining, with sticky ass tires.
Car choice is such a personal thing...I've driven a number of years of Civic SI (though not the new one), and have never cared for them. Don't like fwd handling, don't care for how the engine makes power, etc. Great build quality though, and clearly it's a formula that works for a lot of people; they've been making SI's (continuously?) since 1984.
Grandfather of the Bugeye Mafia
2013 Subaru BRZ Limited
2002 Subaru WRX Bugeyebrid Wagon
there's a crapload of headroom in the wrx ... my cousin who's 7'3" and 350lbs fit tightly but comfortably in my 2010 wrx.
There's the fwd vs awd thing, having diven every type of vehicle motivation known to road going vehicles I personally prefer rwd.. but since that's not a player here awd is really nice to have. Esp when you want to quickly lay down some hp for merging in wet or from a looser surface (side road etc) .. the car will stick and go when you want it to. Which I cannot say for fwd or even my beloved rwd vehicles.
Both take premium fuel.. the SI will need much less to get you the same distance. Boxers aren't notoriously efficient engines to begin with and dragging the extra driveline doesn't help either. However.. the increase in Torque (the part of the power delivery that you feel the most) is worth it to me. At least it makes daily driving much easier. Power sooner is better than later.
The SI will without a doubt outhandle a factory wrx. Hands down it will. That said, there's reasons why the wrx doesn't handle as well and those can be overcome with a couple hundred bucks in sways/endlinks. Out of the box the wrx isn't terrible but it isn't stellar either. The STI is much better in that realm but the extra cost will offset benefit for a daily driver budget.
Community... subaru folks aren't usually known for getting into stupid trouble or being imature. Sure those examples exist but in the scoobie world we tend to run them off or set them straight pretty quickly. Out on the road civics of all kinds are often police magnets. A wrx can get you attention but likely wont get you pulled over for nothing..... at least it shouldn't as long as you're not driving like you stole it . Not that you should be concerned with outward image but it will cast a light on you as the owner depending on the way you go. That sucks, but its a cold hard truth.
OBP 2010 5dr *traded*
SWP 2013 FRS
My name is Shawn, I'm a Devout Practicalist and I'm addicted to flat4's
This page has had 1,666 visits
SUCH IS MANGO!