2002 Camaro was one of the top threeOriginally Posted by uke
I am neither import nor domestic bias and I can say that the E46 M3 is more fun than the Caddy, but the Caddy is also better than the S4 (even the new one). I have also driven all three of them; something that many of you probably have not (taking a wild guess). AWD, while very good is not best for fun (even though I am selling my RWD car for an AWD car..)
The Caddy has an awful shifter, but the M3's is no better and the S4 reminded me of a truck's shifter with its long handle. None of their clutch/shifter combo make me happy.
The power of the Caddy is just there, in strait aways..around turns..braking..G's..etc. IDK how it stacks up in all of those, but it will be 1st in some, 2nd in some, 3rd in some etc.
Styling inside and out is all subjective..but the M3 has the worst interior of them all while the Audi has the worst exterior of them all. I cannot get over that stupid front-end. It looks good in Europe with their long, skinny front plates. But around here it is gross. That leaves the BMW and the Caddy for the exterior and I have no favorites. The Audi has a better interior though.
Just my .02.